Before we dive into how a property division lawyer can help protect your assets, it’s crucial to establish the basic concepts of marital property and separate property. At its core, marital property refers to any assets or debts acquired during a marriage (or, in some states, a common-law relationship). This may include real estate purchased jointly or individually during the marriage, incomes earned, retirement accounts funded, or new debts incurred.
Separate property, on the other hand, generally consists of assets owned by a spouse before entering the marriage or assets received as a gift or inheritance during the marriage, provided those assets were kept separate from marital funds. For example, if you owned a car before marriage and never added your spouse’s name to the title or used joint funds to pay for it, it may remain entirely your asset.
In many states, however, the definitions can become blurred if separate assets become commingled with marital property—for instance, when an inheritance is deposited into a jointly held bank account and used to pay household expenses. Determining whether an asset is wholly or partially marital property can sometimes be more complicated than it first appears. That’s why enlisting the help of a knowledgeable property division lawyer is invaluable to ensure you understand your rights and obligations.
Why Property Division Is More Complex Than You Think
On the surface, property division might sound straightforward: Take all the assets you acquired during the marriage, split them fairly, and move on. Unfortunately, real-life scenarios rarely fit neatly into this box. Here are a few reasons why the process can be far more complicated than most people realize:
1. Commingling of Assets
As previously mentioned, assets you once believed were separate—like an inheritance—can become partly marital property if the funds are blended into joint accounts or used for shared household expenses. Untangling these commingled assets requires careful tracing of where each dollar came from and how it was used.
2. Complex Asset Structures
You may have stocks, stock options, restricted stock units, cryptocurrency, or even complicated business interests. Valuing these assets demands specific knowledge. A property division lawyer can call on forensic accountants and financial experts to assess and value each asset accurately.
3. Debt
Couples often have shared credit card debt, mortgages, and vehicle loans. Deciding who is responsible for these obligations—and in what proportion—forms part of property division. This can be incredibly challenging if one spouse signed for a loan, but both spouses used the loan proceeds during the marriage.
4. Emotional Attachments
Dividing personal items with deep sentimental or emotional value can be a minefield. Property division is not just about cold, complex numbers; it’s also about acknowledging what’s important to each spouse on a personal level.
5. Unclear or Inadequate Prenuptial/Premarital Agreements
Even if you have a prenuptial agreement, disputes can still arise over whether the agreement is valid or whether certain assets are adequately covered under its terms.
Because of these complexities, navigating property division without expert legal support can lead to unintended consequences, including losing out on your fair share of the marital estate.
The Core Responsibilities of a Property Division Lawyer
So, what exactly does a property division lawyer do to protect your assets? While roles can vary slightly depending on the specifics of your case and your state’s laws, an attorney generally takes on the following responsibilities: